You are hereForums / By Discipline / Mountain (off road) / MTB Gear / Car rack.

Car rack.


Jonathan's picture

By Jonathan - Posted on 24 January 2013

NB: Originally posted elsewhere on the Global Riders Network and appears via syndication.

Just curious if anyone has used a bike rack from anaconda they look alright, might give one a go as i don't have a towbar or roof racks.

http://www.anaconda.com.au/Product/Bikes-and-Acc...

Cheers,

Jono.

Tags
hawkeye's picture

It's a pity I didn't have the camera rolling at the time.

The Black Flash had a version of it that failed spectacularly at 110km/hr on the freeway on our boys' weekend away a coupla months ago.

Very lucky to avoid totalling two bikes, very very lucky that it was me following, and very very very lucky that I had spare room on my roof for two bikes and in my car for the dead rack. The damage to the tailgate, which got bent in the incident, was much more expensive.

UV rots the webbing. Use at own risk.

Jonathan's picture

So is it just that particular one or is it that style in general, would i be safe with something like a saris bone?

Black Flash's picture

Just made me shiver at the memory.
In fairness, my straps had really weathered, my bad.
But yes, as hawkeye stated we were very lucky to have him come along. Not only could he carry 2 more bikes (albeit slightly lighter than when they left) but he had room in his car for the rack itself.
So Black flash owes him one....

Back to racks...
Thule 591 on roof racks.

hawkeye's picture

I don't know that I wouldn't have made the same booboo. The straps looked fine to me. Except they weren't.

jbsp1's picture

+1 for the 591. Very convenient, quick to put bike on/off and ready to ride straight away!

Black Flash's picture

Have to organise that weekend again. This time with 4 x 591's on the roof!
See they're so good I've purchased 2 more!!

Jonathan's picture

So ill get the tailgate rack and ill bring hawkeye with me in case Sticking out tongue The problem with the roof ones are that its a really big faff and very expensive to get roof racks for my car as i dont have the rails, along with the fact that the thule 591's are expensive in there own right. Ill end up spending closer to 1k to get roof racks where i could spend that money on my bike rather Smiling

Hmmmmmm, quite a predicament.

And towbar isint an option. And inside my car isint an option either so im sorta limited.

sikllama's picture

Yep a roof or tow bar mount is the only way to go for transporting bikes - I grabbed the 561 fork mounted rack a few months ago and love it. The sales dude said the fork mounted rack holds the bike in a more stable manner but from what I've seen on the road both products seem pretty stable to me.

What wasn't stable though was what I saw coming back from a recent trip down the coast (with a side trip to mogo - awesome mtb park down there by the way for anyone wanting purpose built single track). This guy had a mattress with a mtb strapped on top of it held down with occy straps to his car (no roof racks). Every time he went over 80km/hr the front of the mattress would get air under it and lift up 45 degrees with the bike on it. I was behind this idiot (hope he's not a nobmobber) for about a kilometre before changing lanes and overtaking him - had to laugh.

jbsp1's picture

Thule store Botany. 591s are $195. Have been for ages, plus free shipping aust wide too.
Don't only need Thule bars, I have had my 591s on Holden VE factory racks and now on Mopar racks. They slide straight in.

Worth the investment

leopafe's picture

I too use the 591 and it works a treat even with very fat and square down tubes like on my Giant XTC Composite.

I got mine from Tweeks Cycles for 150 a pop including delivery when ordering 2.

http://www.tweekscycles.com/bike-accessories/car...

GiantNut's picture

Just paid $230 ea for 3 more 591's at Artarmon - Tried to haggle too. Don't go there peps. The dude had a point though - originally I wanted the cheaper version for the inner bikes - but the 591 with the arm allows you to steady the bike. A bike falling on your roof nasty.
I now get 4 on the roof no worries two fwd, two back and no noise, drama's until I try a Macca's drive thru

He keyed them all the same and set them up - perhaps thats why I paid more??

Hasbeen Racing's picture

Go the towbar. Not sure why you say it isn't an option. Cost? Check out these guys, http://cosmopolitantowbars-px.rtrk.com.au/, best priced in Sydney. Get one of these to go with it, http://www.bikeexchange.com.au/bike_accessories/....

I can see why people like roof mounts but I've known too many people who have trashed their bikes on car park entries to ever consider them. Its a pretty stupid mistake but it seems rather common.

hawkeye's picture

Towbar unit with soft jaws and wheel anchors so it doesn't swing is fine for one bike, but if fitting 2 or three it's like a two-wheeled version of Twister trying to get everything in place without the bikes rubbing or knocking on each other and taking off paint or rubbing holes in fork stanchions. Takes ages, and half the time you need to wrap things in rags to prevent damage.

Roof is soooo much simpler. Bikes are up in a minute or two. Just ask Black Flash. We spent longer going ooh-aah at the bikes after the incident than mounting on my roof. (We just won't talk about what I had to do with the rubber mallet Eye-wink ... kidding).

The only significant risk is forgetting about them on the roof and driving somewhere you shouldn't. I haven't done that yet.

GiantNut's picture

Easy decision....Tow bar for my family car is $2500 genuine ( won't impact on-board computer) or $1200 if you wish to risk it (Audi) Should have got it thrown from new but they are also ugly.
4 roof bars approx $800....had one already so $600.

As per Hawkeye - having used tow bar mounts on prior cars all different types..... basically a great way to scratch your bikes. I protected mine by wrapping everything PIA but the kids bikes got smashed.

N76's picture

Whilst slightly pricey compared to Saris Bone, I've been using the Thule 9001 '2 Bike' rack for a good while and have done numerous trips down the Freeway to Wingello with no concerns once on the road.

I will say that that fitting two bikes simultaneously does require you bring your Tetris 'A' game. Unfortunately with the model I have the horizontal arms the bikes sit on are fixed and with the geometry of most XC bikes this means the bikes sit on a fair angle however no where near as precarious as the upside down/sideways mounted kiddies bikes seen on the backs of cars over the Christmas holidays - strewth!

Hasbeen Racing's picture

It does seem to be roadies that trash their bikes. MTBers must be smarter.

browndog's picture

If you could do a towbar the racks from GripSport are excellent, have recently purchased the two bike downhill version and loving it.

http://www.gripsport.com.au/products

Simon's picture

Two DH bikes on tow bar with grip sport rack.

Two DH bikes on roof. Bike racks were made for a case of beer at a Northern Beaches fabrication workshop out of scrap aluminium.

Solid as. You can pay a lot for injection moulded plastic.

tech.itch's picture

Try this place on ebay for car racks
http://stores.ebay.com.au/Roof-Rack-City

Just got the Swagman hitch rack, very happy with the quality and low price

Mamil's picture

Jono, if you're looking for something that attaches to the back of a hatchback like that Anaconda one, but doesn't have those poxy webbing straps, check out the Thule 9103/9104. It's a similar principle, but is a lot more solid and secure, takes three bikes, and costs about $200.

http://www.thule.com.au/details.php?p_id=64&list...

I've been using mine for about five years and can highly recommend it.

Jonathan's picture

That looks and sounds promising. I take it you can't open the boot with it attached can you? Wheres the best place to get one?

Im in sydney for reference.

Cheers,

Jono

Mamil's picture

Yep, it locks onto the tailgate not the car body, so you can open the boot with it attached, even with two bikes on if you're strong enough!

I'm in Perth, bought mine at LBS who was a Thule stockist, but I guess anyone in Sydney who does Thule would be able to order one in - Thule have a storefinder on their website if you're stuck - http://www.thule.com.au/store-finder

There's a few different models depending on the shape of your car, so if you're gonna order online check this Thule guide first to see which one is right for your particular car - http://www.thule.com.au/images/product/file/Rear...

Oldernslower's picture

Just a comment which you may already know of - many people and manufacturers don't recommend carrying carbon frames by the top tube. Though many riders do with no problems (yet?) but a few have and regretted it. If carbon frame then a carrier that holds the bike by the wheels may be more applicable. eg. Thule, Grip?? means a tow bar mounted carrier though.

Scottboy's picture

if you got a towbar hitch I would go the rhino 3 bike platform rack , I have one similar & happy with it , otherwise go with a good named rack to go on your hatchback presuming you have a hatchback car ?

Jonathan's picture

No tow bar or roof racks, and no carbon bike either. My mum has all the goodies on her car thou so this rack for my car (hatchback) is just for during the week running around locally so only short trips (20 min max). When i wanna do longer runs i can always use my mums car.

So the thule raceway option looks to be quite promising, how hard is it to scratch a car with the hooks/straps?

Cheers

Jonathan's picture

How does the thule compare with the saris bone? Both are the same style, but is the thule worth the extra $100.00?

Floydo's picture

http://www.isi-carriers.com/products.html
Australian made tough. I have taken my bikes all over the outback, Simpson desert, Birdesville track. Believe me these aren't the places you want to be stuck with a busted bike rack. I can have my bike off the rack before you roof carriers, have even the first wheel strap undone.
Got a qspear and a rhino roof discovery, and the isi carrier is way better. Yes it is a little more expensive, but holds the bike solid, even over the roughest ground. Always have a laugh at people who spend mega bucks on carbon bikes, and then throw them on a cheap rack.

Jonathan's picture

They look really nice. Except.... that they look like there tow ball mounted...

Is that the case?

Jonathan's picture

Out of curiosity does anyone have a thule 9001 i could possibly try fit my bike too? I was thinking about it and with my suspension design im really not sure if the bike will fit on the rack. Preferable someone close to cascades as i have a hard time transporting my bike Sticking out tongue :P

flubberghusted's picture

Tend to agree that the 591's are the best options for convenience and ease, whereas the towbar options offer less drag and better fuel econ on long haul trips.

Double up on the security locks when leaving it out in public for extended periods though.
I cringe at the notion of key rotation number system Thule has.
You dont want this to happen to ya ...


http://youtu.be/0Yu4vEsD9WA

muvro's picture

if possible, as said, try and get a tow bar and Tb mounted rack. I originally made a twin bike rack for the back, now run a Thule XTR 917 extension and extended the pipe to fit in the rack. Much cheaper option compared to the main unit with the hinge setup to open the tailgate with loaded rack.

Only reason I went to the 917 was the way it grabs the tyres, as my old rack was a bracket that grabbed the frame. Extremely secure way to do it, but limited, as I could only run my model bikes, running somoene elses that wasn't the same, it wouldn't fit in. I had a solution for it, but didn't like it. This 917 rack takes anything from a mtb, roady, to 29r and literally takes about 10-15secs to load. Add 5-10 secs if you want to use the built in wire rope lock. You can also add key barrels to the actuale release mechanism for extra security. I haven't bothered with them and leave them in carparks etc. People don't often carry bolt cutters or cordless angle grinders on the off chance they find a locked up bike. lol If they do, they're insured.

lorax's picture

I borrowed an Anaconda style rack when I went to New Zealand last year. It was easy to disassemble and put in the bike box with my bike. Both bike and rack were well under the 23kg weight limit. I was able to easily assemble the rack and bike at the airport (flew into Auckland) and fit it to the hire car. I was able to get away with a Camry rather than the more expensive 4wd option that was the only way to get roof racks. The rack performed flawlessly for the whole trip. I can't really comment on the longevity of the straps, and I'm sure with constant use you're bound to take some paint of the car with the mounting hooks. But it was a great solution for taking my own bike OS. And yes Rotorua single track is awesome.

Lionel's picture

Hi all,
I'm new to this site and already learned a bucket load on bike racks which I'm currently looking at buying for my forester. Can anyone who owns a forester recommends a specific model/brand? Also if anyone has a second hand one for sale? I'd be looking for the tow ball hitch type for 4 bikes, with the tilt mechanism would be a bonus from what I've been reading here.

Ricos's picture

+1 for ISI-4x4 carriers, best money spent. easy to fit easy to secure bikes & locks. as said earlier why buy cheap when you spend thousands on bikes. Also great George from ISI is a rider himself so he knows what is needed.

Ian_A's picture

I also drive a Forester (running heavy duty king springs in the rear) and I've got a torpedo 7 4 bike platform carrier. It doesn't tilt, which is a bit of a pain. I have only had 3 bikes on it so far, but it held them fine. It actually sits up pretty high and the back is higher than the front to improve clearance - mine is yet to scrape on anything.
It attaches to the towball with clawlike metal things and you tighten them up, then tighten a bolt to stop it from undoing. Very secure. There is also a base plate that stops it from rotating but needs to be removed to tow a trailer.
I was almost set on an ISI but their before sales service was terrible and they couldn't even answer simple questions. Any email, PM on rotorburn or question in a thread resulted in the same copied and pasted answer. They wouldn't return emails or PM's when asked specific questions. I didn't bother with them.
The torpedo 7 one is very basic and I don't see it lasting more than a few years but it was only $180 so worst case is I buy a new rack in the future. The bikes are secure which is the main thing, but straps to hold bikes on will never last - I'll add some clips in the future.

Lionel's picture

Thanks again for sharing the info!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Best Mountain Bike